- The manipulation of social media will impact campaigning for the 12 December UK general election and may threaten the integrity of the vote.
- Manipulation will target the most emotive campaign topics such as Brexit and the NHS.
- Groups seeking to influence UK politics or profit off advertising will use various types of manipulation to access the widest audience.
- This will polarise key political discourse, which, amid uncertainty over polling, may impact the vote and even the credibility of the result.
Role of social media
The UK social media community is sufficiently large to influence the general election. Around 45 percent of the population uses Facebook daily. Twitter and Instagram have 16 and 14 million UK daily users respectively. Daily use may also increase over the election period.
Assess the extent of social media manipulation is difficult. In March, Facebook reported it had taken down more than 100 UK-based inauthentic accounts, including far-right activists, some of which had more than 175,000 followers on the platform.
Misinformation will focus on the most emotive and polarising of political topics. The UK’s planned departure from the EU will be the largest target. A 14 November YouGov survey indicated voters identified more with a particular stance on Brexit than by political party. Brexit proposals for the leading parties and their members present the most susceptible target for manipulation on social media. Other campaign topics vulnerable to manipulation include the NHS, taxation, and efforts to tackle violent crime.
Methods of social media manipulation
PGI’s election monitoring team follow previously apolitical social media discussion groups repurposed in order to spam content and distribute false news articles. The administrator of a Facebook group or the owner of a Twitter feed can manipulate discussion by changing group names, flooding the narrative space with targeted political messaging, or changing openness settings from ‘public’ to ‘private’ to isolate a community and build echo chambers.
Such behaviour is commonly observed on social media platforms. In the group identified by Facebook in March, it noted that the groups and accounts changed names to attract more followers from various political backgrounds.
One example identified by PGI provides a clear example of the risk of foreign influence operations targeting the UK election. A Moscow-based administrator, identified as John, runs a central pro-Brexit Facebook page with six subsidiary groups, all promoting Brexit to a direct audience of more than 40,000 individuals. The administrator also manages three other ostensibly apolitical groups about bitcoin trading and expat communities, into which they feed regular pro-Brexit articles and recommend that members join the politicised groups operating under the central page.
John’s identity, whether authentic inauthentic, and his motive, whether financial of political, are unclear. However, the effects of his group remain, pushing politicised pro-Brexit narratives to a widening audience.
A less sophisticated form of social media manipulation is the spamming of the general election information space with hashtags, pictures or comments supporting their narrative and attacking narratives of their opponents. When social media users search a topic, algorithms return the most popular posts and trends. The most popular, the logic runs, is the most posted.
Gaming the algorithms is relatively easy for entities maintaining significant numbers of profiles on social media sites. For instance, one pro-Labour account floods Instagram with repurposed anti-Conservative posts. Each post’s hashtags are the same, targeting both what would otherwise be genuine political conversations within #conservativeparty, and apolitical conversations within #asda.
Pseudo News Sites
Social media serves as an aggregator for news articles on the general election. If users share articles bearing false narratives, audiences of thousands within online communities will be misinformed. Pseudo news sources came to prominence in 2016, with thousands being run with polemic narratives to generate advertising revenue. Often, links from pseudo news sources attempt to gain on-sight credibility by imitating names of mainstream outlets, such as CNNN, or doctor thumbnails to replicate those of the BBC. Such details are often overlooked in the rapid scroll of social media content. In the heated Brexit debate, misinformation might be supported by a brexitnews.tv link to add veracity to the claim.
Misinformation will have a lasting impact on political discourse in the UK by polarising narratives on key voting issues. In an environment where no parties are polling at a majority, a significant level of misinformation may affect the results of the 12 December vote. Even a small change in the vote may alter the course of coalition negotiations.
If it emerges that there has been a significant extent of misinformation during campaigning, there is a chance of lasting grievances, and questions over the legitimacy of the vote. If evidence, or perceived evidence, of social media manipulation by a foreign government or a political party arises, this could have serious political consequences and further damage the integrity of UK democracy.
PGI’s Intelligence specialists provide business intelligence and geopolitical risk analysis to multinational corporations and governments worldwide. For more information on how they can assist your organisation, please contact us: email@example.com
Your free global geopolitical
PGI’s Risk Portal tool provides daily intelligence feeds, country threat assessments and analytical insights, enabling clients to track, understand and navigate geopolitical threats.
The Risk Portal gives users up-to-date information and analysis on global affairs.
The Risk Portal allows users to visualise information in a unique and instantly understandable way. Mapping filters enable the visualisation of incidents by threat category, time period, perpetrator and target type.
Risk Portal users can upgrade their accounts to include the Report Builder and Country Profile Generator features. The Report Builder allows users to select information, data and images from the Risk Portal and create bespoke reports and emails.
Subscribers to PGI’s Bespoke services receive tailored analysis on specific sectors and geographies of interest, delivered at a frequency they determine.
Making ongoing compliance easier for you and your business
GDPR is now in force. Make sure your business meets the necessary requirements, providing assurance for all of your customers and employees.
A full audit of your business to assess the level of your compliance against GDPR requirements.
Become GDPR compliant with minimal work. We will conduct an analysis, review, report and implement any necessary changes to your business.
We will conduct simple security assessments to help you understand and mitigate the potential risks to your business.
Get your business ready to face the cyber challenge.
We provide a full range of accredited, certified and bespoke services that assess the resilience of your cyber security posture.
PGI’s Qualified Security Assessors (QSA) will help you meet Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards (PCI DSS).
Find out more on PCI DSS
Demonstrate your commitment to cyber security by achieving and maintaining accreditation for the globally-recognised information security standard.
Find out more on ISO 27001
Understand the threats of phishing and malware to avoid being targeted.
Undertake our phishing vulnerability assessment to reduce your organisation’s risk of attack, by measuring the cyber awareness of your workforce.
PGI will conduct a tailored phishing campaign, using multiple methods, to identify realism and train employees where necessary to mitigate future attacks.
PGI monitor multiple metrics to identify the types of phishing, generate in-depth analytical reports and provide an informed decision to help improve your organisation’s level of security and awareness.
Prevent attacks, respond to breaches and protect your business.
Our bespoke range of cyber security services not only protect your critical assets but provide the education you need to keep your operations and data safe.
Implement this cost-effective cyber security measure launched by the government to prevent cyber-attacks, demonstrate information security commitment to your clients, and attract new business by being recognised as a secure organisation.
Find out more on Cyber Essentials Accreditation
The most effective way to identify how attackers target your organisation’s weaknesses is by evaluating your system, your network security, and reporting on any vulnerabilities that could have an impact on your business.
Find out more on Penetration Testing
If your business has experienced breaches, network compromises or operational disruption, our team of cyber security specialists can deploy quickly, and will begin the process of detecting and eliminating the threat efficiently.
Find out more on Data Breach Response & Recovery
Data Breach Response & Recovery
We prevent attacks, respond to security breaches, and protect your business
Our team of specialists can deploy quickly and efficiently to begin the process of detecting, eliminating and preventing future threats of a breach.
A vital part of the response process is making a copy of your data for safe forensic analysis. We will work with you to preserve and use this evidence to discover the extent of an intrusion.
Find out more on Digital Forensics
We will identify and minimise the risks, as well as the possibility of future risks to your business.
Consistent interaction with your management team and recommendations on how to approach all outcomes that need attention.
Subscribe to our Cyber Bytes Newsletter
Keep yourself in the loop with PGI by signing up to our Monthly Cyber Bytes email. You will receive updates, tips and narrative around what has been happening in the world of information security.